A concrete slab and a block wall get treated as the same material and they are not close. One is solid and horizontal. The other is hollow, vertical, jointed, and busy moving water around inside itself.
Block does not behave like concrete
A block wall is an assembly. Units with hollow cores, mortar joints between them, and in Florida usually a stucco skin over the top. Each of those parts takes up water at a different rate and lets it go at a different rate.
Mortar joints are the weak line. They are more porous than the block and they are where a coating is most likely to lift first, which is why a wall can look fine across its faces and be failing along every joint.
A mile from the Atlantic changes the problem
Hobe Sound sits between the Intracoastal and the ocean, and salt-laden air reaches walls that never see a wave. Chloride works its way into porous masonry, and once it is in, it stays and it draws moisture.
The white powdery bloom that shows up on block and stucco is efflorescence: salts carried to the surface by water moving out through the wall. It is not mould and washing it off does not fix it. It is the wall telling you water is getting in somewhere and leaving through the face.
Coating over active efflorescence is the most common mistake on walls here. The salt keeps arriving, it crystallises under the film instead of on top of it, and it pushes the coating off from behind.
Breathability is the whole argument
Every block wall takes up some water, from rain, from sprinklers, from humidity. The only question is whether it can let that water back out.
A coating with good vapour permeability keeps liquid water out while letting vapour through, so the wall dries from the face. A fully sealed coating stops water going in at the face and does nothing about what arrives from the ground, from a leak or from the other side. That water collects behind the film.
This is why heavy waterproof coatings fail on walls that were never designed to be sealed, and why they fail dramatically when they go. The film comes away carrying the surface of the wall with it.
Where masonry coatings earn their money
Garden and privacy walls take the worst of it, because they are exposed on both faces and sit in wet ground along the bottom. Pool enclosure walls deal with chlorine and constant splash. House skirts and columns get the ground level damage that nothing else on the building has to handle.
On all of them the same rule applies: the coating stops above grade. A finish carried down into soil or mulch wicks moisture behind itself for as long as the wall stands.
Masonry coating questions
What is the white powder on my wall?
Efflorescence. Salts carried to the surface by water moving out through the masonry. It means water is getting into the wall somewhere, so the useful work is finding out where rather than scrubbing the wall.
Is a masonry coating the same as exterior paint?
They overlap, but a masonry coating is built thicker, bridges fine cracking better, and is formulated for an alkaline surface. Standard house paint on bare block tends to fail at the mortar joints first.
Should I waterproof the wall completely?
Usually not. A wall that cannot dry out through its face holds whatever water reaches it from the ground or from behind, and that is how coatings come off in sheets. Keeping liquid water out while letting vapour through is what lasts here.
